It's not practical or anybody's job to do this.
This so much.... I frenquently receive PM like "hey Afa which is better for leaden? Mab+30 wsd+3 or mab +20 wsd +8?". Everytime I had to facepalm with this kind of message.
Because in order to find out, I will have to reply the PM with "sup, can you tell me what is your total mab/wsd/agi in entire set", pop my spreadsheet, add their augments to the spreadsheet , then give them the answer based on the result. And it's faster if people use the spreadsheet to find out themselves. If I find the answer for them it would be doing the job that one person can do with the man hour of 2 person.
Don't get me wrong, When it comes to playstyle discussions and "builds" to accomplish certain result, or how to use certain niche gears. I'm always open to discuss and offer my opinion about them even if its not always right.
But when it comes to things that's hard dps math, I cant be more accurate than a spreadsheet or calculation. Because that's the source to all the answers I have to begin with. It's so much more efficient to find out in a spreadsheet than expecting the guide to cover 12345678 possible gear combinations for certain results.
It would be nice to see what the minimum MAB+AGI would be to do 18k/23k @ 1k 2k and 3k (with obi pixie+1 and archon) Disregarding tpbonus because *** wotg.
Would help people get started instead of just telling them "this best get it or *** off"
It'd be nice, to see it on here, for everyone. Like that xenius guy is shouting right now for a oneshot leaden cor. I'll bet that 100% of people that would be interested have no idea if they can do it or not.
If they do not know, they can ask about stats HP, download the spreadsheet, add their gears, get the ws number, add tp until ws number matches mob hp.
It's not practical to create a set, in a game with random augments, and tell people "hey, you need mab+20 wsd+1 herc legs, mab+10 wsd+5 herc feet to one shot statue, but if you have malaise, you can use this...blah blah"in a guide.
Nobody tell me if I'm ready to one shot statue when I started, and how much TP do I need to one shot them. I just do it, eventually found that 1500 tp works. As my gear got better I lower it to 1300. That's all I do. So can anybody.
And if people aren't willing to join a pug dyna D pt unless a guide tell them exactly what they need to 1 shot a statue, I question if they are ready for this event anyways. Doing research is part of playing ffxi since launch.