|
|
SE wants you to bring along "gimp" players...
Quetzalcoatl.Nikanoru
Server: Quetzalcoatl
Game: FFXI
Posts: 4
By Quetzalcoatl.Nikanoru 2013-06-25 09:38:52
you need a job to buy a car and you need a car to get to a job. that's the situation us returning players or newbies are put in.
you want us to have the best gear to participate in delve and all the best gear comes from delve. my server doesn't have shouts for anything but delve (and theyre few and far between).
there's a feeling of being ostracized as soon as i log into ff11. and it just makes me want to log off, cancel my fee, and go play something else.
you might say, 'good, who needs you anyway. you're gimp in my eyes." well the truth is you do need us. as subscriptions go down SE will have to consider canceling services. and, with fewer new people to enter the game, the select people on servers that act like elitists, and total lack of anything to do but delve ff11 is going to become an empty game.
Valefor.Sehachan
Server: Valefor
Game: FFXI
Posts: 24219
By Valefor.Sehachan 2013-06-25 09:41:04
You don't jump on top of a ladder, you climb it.
Server: Cerberus
Game: FFXI
Posts: 4415
By Cerberus.Senkyuutai 2013-06-25 09:41:24
server merges needs to be done ^
Valefor.Sehachan
Server: Valefor
Game: FFXI
Posts: 24219
By Valefor.Sehachan 2013-06-25 09:46:10
I agree with that, I know it's problematic for the market but in my opinion it could be beneficial.
Fenrir.Camiie
Server: Fenrir
Game: FFXI
Posts: 817
By Fenrir.Camiie 2013-06-25 09:47:12
Well that's your problem. Why should others do things for you?
Doesn't that go both ways though? Why should I do things for others?
Quote: Some people here should stop demanding things.
They should. Leaders should stop demanding gear beyond the level required for victory.
Quote: I hate teaming up with strangers too, but such is the game, you eventually have to do it to get through stuff, or else you'll not experience the rest of it.
Strawman. I haven't seen anyone here have a problem with this.
You don't jump on top of a ladder, you climb it.
But even with the speed of leveling these days if you take the time to do things right you're just getting left further and further behind. You'll never catch up that way.
Asura.Ina
Server: Asura
Game: FFXI
Posts: 17912
By Asura.Ina 2013-06-25 09:48:14
Well that's your problem. Why should others do things for you? Some people here should stop demanding things.
I hate teaming up with strangers too, but such is the game, you eventually have to do it to get through stuff, or else you'll not experience the rest of it. Arguably their problem then becomes a problem for everyone in the group else then. Some people are naturally leaders, some people can work to become a leader, and some people just don't have it in them for one reason or another (and there is nothing wrong with that). If someone is lacking in necessary skills to keep 17 others in line and organized there is a good chance it will just waste everyone's time.
Not forming a group =/= asking everything to be handed to them. There are no shortage of people that have the capacity to contribute strongly to a run however are held back by not having the gear that is now considered standard.
You don't jump on top of a ladder, you climb it.
I'll say it again, SE designed the event so that you are expected to have cleared previous content before doing it. But SEs intentions have never really been relevant to our community (see ninja becoming a tank). You may have been able to get by with Skirmish weapons initially, but now unless you have a reputation as a good player that won't cut it. The difference is simply too big, and delve weapons too numerous among the community now to accept less.
Going with the metaphor it's like climbing a ladder only to find out there are there are too many steps missing for you to reach the next one.
[+]
Quetzalcoatl.Nikanoru
Server: Quetzalcoatl
Game: FFXI
Posts: 4
By Quetzalcoatl.Nikanoru 2013-06-25 09:51:24
there's no climbing the ladder anymore. there's the people on top and the people on the bottom.
and even if there was a ladder finding anyone else to climb with you is difficult.
Server: Cerberus
Game: FFXI
Posts: 4415
By Cerberus.Senkyuutai 2013-06-25 09:52:08
You don't jump on top of a ladder, you climb it. The problem is that the ladder is:
1) missing a lot of steps
2) lots of steps cannot be done
How do you climb something that has "holes"?
When you make a ladder oriented game and even the people on the highest steps react like "well, I'll just go play something else", you have to stop, think and come up with a proper explanation.
People aren't just whiners asking things to be handed to them, you need to understand this. The way SoA is doesn't work in 2013. It would have back in 2007, but not in 2013.
Too many people are quitting, and this is certainly not because of FFXIV. You need to open your eyes.
Bismarck.Aselin
Server: Bismarck
Game: FFXI
Posts: 397
By Bismarck.Aselin 2013-06-25 09:55:59
Let me get this out of the way because I'm noticing a trend here by the "elitist player posts" in this thread.
A lot of the posts are beginning to get closer and closer to something I have not agreed with for a long time and never will: Pushing or imposing one's morals, beliefs, or religion upon another person without their permission or acceptance. I will never agree to fundamentalist religious groups doing that in real life (Catholics, Islamists, Westboro Babptist, etc.); and I will never agree to elitist players doing similar in the game, even if it is not a religion they're imposing or pushing upon others.
You cannot and will never be able to hold people to the same standards as you. Even if I said all that above, I will not push that onto another person in this game. Everyone is different and everyone plays and learns differently at different rates and methods. And, as you can tell from that hint, I am the same way in real life, which is why I am opposed to such things as the "No Child Left Behind Act."
This is not just about tolerating another player in a game or a person in real life. But, if I cannot accept the differences of others, sympathize and empathize with them, then it makes me no different than the other elitist players on this server in this game, and no different than a racist and prejudicial person in real life.
I am not that and I have not been raised that way. Regardless if I have taken twelve years of private Catholic education, I have not chosen any religion to belong to like Catholicism. However, I have also learned a lot of things about Catholicism in regards on how to treat others in real life. And, I have carried that into this game as well.
People need to be treated with respect, and one must try to understand their situation, empathize and sympathize with it or you will never understand the "why" and "how".
People are different. They are not you or I. We are all unique individuals here. We all have our own needs, wants, and desires. We also have our own problems, intentions, and situations that may affect us in real life. The same can be said of any player in this game and any other MMO.
If you continually expect others to be perfect or be at the same standards as yourself, then you will eventually run into another problem I have: "You cannot expect people to be perfect all the time, or you'll eventually hit a dead end or get closer to it." This is already happening in this game. The population of actual skilled players is smaller than the entire population of unskilled players-- new or returning players. And, expecting only skilled players or perfect players to join a pick up group will eventually lead people to shouting for hours on the server. Other so-called "skilled players" may already have a Linkshell or their own static to do these events. Shouting for hours in "/yell" for hours means you are either reaching that eventual dead end when you cannot find the right players or it takes a long time to get them.
Yes, hold others to a certain standard or level or play skill, but do not set the barrier too high or try to raise every player's skillset and knowledge about endgame as you have. Not everyone has had the time to learn it and many have not been given the opportunity to do so. At the same time, these players will have to learn about it themselves eventually and have to be willing to learn them and gear themselves appropriately. Until then, they will need to join these groups to learn and will need a willing teacher to teach them.
Also, not everyone is a leader, and that holds true in real life outside the game. You cannot expect others to be able to lead a group competently and assuredly from beginning to end. Leadership is learned and earned through hard work and effort, but they have to start from somewhere and that means going to these endgame events and learning how they work. We are all players who have been in the same shoes years before when we first started in FFXI and have learned from each other how to play the game. Now, when players are returning to the game or new players are joining, regardless how small the number is, do we have to turn a blind eye to them? No, because they will never learn anything that way.
I like to see everything from both sides of the coin, from both sides of the situation or problem. It's the only way you can eventually find a solution or a compromise between the two.
Server: Bismarck
Game: FFXI
Posts: 2854
By Bismarck.Bloodbathboy 2013-06-25 09:56:33
Well that's your problem. Why should others do things for you? Some people here should stop demanding things.
I hate teaming up with strangers too, but such is the game, you eventually have to do it to get through stuff, or else you'll not experience the rest of it. Arguably their problem then becomes a problem for everyone in the group else then. Some people are naturally leaders, some people can work to become a leader, and some people just don't have it in them for one reason or another (and there is nothing wrong with that). If someone is lacking in necessary skills to keep 17 others in line and organized there is a good chance it will just waste everyone's time.
Not forming a group =/= asking everything to be handed to them. There are no shortage of people that have the capacity to contribute strongly to a run however are held back by not having the gear that is now considered standard.
You don't jump on top of a ladder, you climb it.
I'll say it again, SE designed the event so that you are expected to have cleared previous content before doing it. But SEs intentions have never really been relevant to our community (see ninja becoming a tank). You may have been able to get by with Skirmish weapons initially, but now unless you have a reputation as a good player that won't cut it. The difference is simply too big, and delve weapons too numerous among the community now to accept less.
Going with the metaphor it's like climbing a ladder only to find out there are there are too many steps missing for you to reach the next one. I was thinking about coming back. But I only have NNI gear and empys though. And I guess now that's sub- par.
Valefor.Sehachan
Server: Valefor
Game: FFXI
Posts: 24219
By Valefor.Sehachan 2013-06-25 09:56:41
Strawman. I haven't seen anyone here have a problem with this No strawman, the person above me mentioned their anecdotal problem with leading, I mentioned mine.
Either way I see only excuses. You want the top tier, you take the mid tier first. Nobody invited Hagun sam to VW, get with the times if you're behind, it's not impossible to do. I did salvage duo in a month. And not because I'm awesome, but because it's easy to do the previous content, for anyone.
Valefor.Sehachan
Server: Valefor
Game: FFXI
Posts: 24219
By Valefor.Sehachan 2013-06-25 09:57:46
Cerberus.Senkyuutai said: »Too many people are quitting, and this is certainly not because of FFXIV. You need to open your eyes. Never claimed delve to be awesome. I'm somewhat bored with the game as well lately.
Lakshmi.Feint
Server: Lakshmi
Game: FFXI
Posts: 332
By Lakshmi.Feint 2013-06-25 09:59:59
After putting together a decent amount of alliances, I found that proper leadership is needed for many of these fights. Gear and good play is important but some of this can be made up for by having a good set up and strategy. For example, having 3 bards swapping before popping the NM allows even bad players to WS spam. Tier 4 morimar seems to be the most difficult for a pick-up though.
I do agree with a lot of you on this thread, gear sets do make a difference as well.
Valefor.Sehachan
Server: Valefor
Game: FFXI
Posts: 24219
By Valefor.Sehachan 2013-06-25 10:02:02
Re:Aselin
I do not impose any standard, but Delve megabosses require something, and it is not me who decided this, but the game designers. For everything below I simply incourage to fill the necessary gaps to be viable. Did you notice I said skirmish augments are enough to farm 30k points for a delve weapon? Yeah. I have more opened standards than I'm given credit for.
Server: Cerberus
Game: FFXI
Posts: 4415
By Cerberus.Senkyuutai 2013-06-25 10:05:04
Cerberus.Senkyuutai said: »Too many people are quitting, and this is certainly not because of FFXIV. You need to open your eyes. Never claimed delve to be awesome. I'm somewhat bored with the game as well lately. I know you didn't, what I meant is that the game as a whole is chasing people away.
Delve is I think a very good event, it's just not coming at the right time and the rest of the game doesn't make players who can't do it able to achieve anything substantial.
I remember back in TOAU days, not everyone was doing Salvage but I can talk to many players and they'll tell me how happy they were to do Nyzul.
Says a lot to me.
[+]
Asura.Ina
Server: Asura
Game: FFXI
Posts: 17912
By Asura.Ina 2013-06-25 10:09:07
Bismarck.Bloodbathboy said: »I was thinking about coming back. But I only have NNI gear and empys though. And I guess now that's sub- par. Empys definitely unless they are 99, I think some salvage gear is useful. If you have/make friends that will take you for delve NM kills and a couple plasm runs it is very easy to get caught up. If you would be relying on random groups and a couple friends in similar positions to you you'll still be able to get caught up but will need to form your own groups most likely.
Fenrir.Camiie
Server: Fenrir
Game: FFXI
Posts: 817
By Fenrir.Camiie 2013-06-25 10:10:21
Strawman. I haven't seen anyone here have a problem with this No strawman, the person above me mentioned their anecdotal problem with leading, I mentioned mine.
You said that:
Quote: I hate teaming up with strangers too, but such is the game, you eventually have to do it to get through stuff, or else you'll not experience the rest of it.
I don't recall anyone saying they had issues teaming up with strangers. Some of us do have issues leading those strangers. That's a bit of a distinction, don't you think?
Quote: Either way I see only excuses. You want the top tier, you take the mid tier first. Nobody invited Hagun sam to VW, get with the times if you're behind, it's not impossible to do. I did salvage duo in a month. And not because I'm awesome, but because it's easy to do the previous content, for anyone.
People are taking the mid tier and being told point blank that it's not good enough. In many eyes you must already have the top tier to be able to do the top tier, because IMO a lot of leaders want to be carried through the content by people who have already done it rather than actually work through the progression themselves.
Valefor.Sehachan
Server: Valefor
Game: FFXI
Posts: 24219
By Valefor.Sehachan 2013-06-25 10:14:24
What is that you don't understand about anecdote? Are you arguing just for the sake of it? It was no strawman.
By daemun 2013-06-25 10:15:30
In light of where this conversation is gone ill give my 2cents worth. I have quit the game a few times now for various reasons, and am now returning after a nearly 2 year lapse. I am under leveled, under geared and have no idea how to play any of the new content.
I will, however, do my best to two-box as much content as I possibly can in order to get where I can before asking help and also to get a feel for the game again. Where I find people kind enough to help me, I will return the favor and do my best to assist them. I will treat all this new content just like I did the first time I set foot in sky or sea. I will listen to any and all constructive criticism, ask regularly of leadership my job and my place, I will frivolously attempt to gain knowledge of each situation and continue to implement it as I go forward.
For anyone on Odin, if you are willing to allow a "gimp" to join your ranks, tag along, and do his best to be an asset, I will reward you with becoming a key member as soon as it is possible for me to obtain the necessary gear and skills. I shall ask nothing of you other than patience and wisdom. Fair enough proposition ffxiah?
[+]
Bismarck.Aselin
Server: Bismarck
Game: FFXI
Posts: 397
By Bismarck.Aselin 2013-06-25 10:21:19
Re:Aselin
I do not impose any standard, but Delve megabosses require something, and it is not me who decided this, but the game designers. For everything below I simply incourage to fill the necessary gaps to be viable. Did you notice I said skirmish augments are enough to farm 30k points for a delve weapon? Yeah. I have more opened standards than I'm given credit for. Yes, I remember you mentioning that. Skirmish weapons are a nice stopgap before Delve weapons or 99 R/E/M weapons. However, even Skirmish groups are picky on our servers and shouts for pick up groups are very, very rare. I've noticed they're mostly done between friends that know each other's skill level and understanding of how to play and gear their job; or it's done exclusively within an LS where long-time members that have played together the longest in the LS know each other well and will only invite them even within the LS. So, it's like an exclusive club within an LS.
If anyone is like me, I do not have many skilled friends that are willing to help especially those who have done Delve or other things like Meeble Burrows, and majority of them have not done Skirmish or Delve even. There are players like me in the very same situation. I've only done two Skirmish runs since I've returned, but was only invited because the people they usually go with are not available at the time I went. And, I'm still too inexperienced to even lead one myself. I would have to do more to learn how it's done. Again, there are players in my same situation-- having not done Skirmish or too little of it to even be competent enough to lead a pick up group themselves.
So, Skirmish weapons are out of the question for these kind of players.
If we're going to bring this standard to things outside of Delve and the Delve NMs for the key items, then it's going to be difficult to let inexperienced players, new players, and returning players to get into these endgame events, and eventually newer content that gets introduced.
Like I said above, even if the player is willing to learn, they still need a willing player to teach them and what they can and cannot do. Everyone is different, and they learn differently. These players will eventually have to be invited or they'll never learn anything at all as to how these endgame contents work. Or else, we're going to see a very lopsided and eventually small subset of the playerbase that are both skilled and geared to do these events where it becomes an exclusive "country club" excluding others that are not "like them" to the group. It's already happening and is happening-- only LS play with LS people, only friends play with longtime friends. New and returning players to these content? They're, as how many have put it in this thread, "***out of luck", to summarize it in a nutshell.
Siren.Mosin
By Siren.Mosin 2013-06-25 10:24:41
wow what did this turn into?
people who love the new gear grind vs. those that love old ffxi?
almost interesting.
I said *** it & played LoL all night last night. sucked it up though. :(
Asura.Ccl
Server: Asura
Game: FFXI
Posts: 1998
By Asura.Ccl 2013-06-25 10:25:06
I did make my own groups on occasion, and I joined most shouts on Cor until I got Bereaver. If I responded to a shout with "I have Skirmish GS" I`d either get a no thanks or no reply at all.
Well you're on Asura, we have people here shouting for Oatixur mnk for 8k plasm farm in Ceizak.
[+]
Asura.Ina
Server: Asura
Game: FFXI
Posts: 17912
By Asura.Ina 2013-06-25 10:28:18
I can defend people not wanting to form delve groups because 17 randoms is a pain and a half to keep sorted out and in line. Skimish on the other had is simple enough and easily accessed enough that it is hard to say someone shouldn't feel comfortable shouting for that. It is about as complicated as an exp party and don't even need very good gear to clear.
That said I still wouldn't count on a skirmish weapon to get you into delve groups unless skirmish 2 provides a reasonable gap closer.
[+]
Valefor.Sehachan
Server: Valefor
Game: FFXI
Posts: 24219
By Valefor.Sehachan 2013-06-25 10:28:45
people who love the new gear grind vs. those that love old ffxi I vote for ToAU times. Ground Kings always seemed bs to me and sky/sea are dreadful to farm, so that's what I'd say was the best endgame to me!
[+]
Fenrir.Camiie
Server: Fenrir
Game: FFXI
Posts: 817
By Fenrir.Camiie 2013-06-25 10:30:04
In light of where this conversation is gone ill give my 2cents worth. I have quit the game a few times now for various reasons, and am now returning after a nearly 2 year lapse. I am under leveled, under geared and have no idea how to play any of the new content.
I will, however, do my best to two-box as much content as I possibly can in order to get where I can before asking help and also to get a feel for the game again. Where I find people kind enough to help me, I will return the favor and do my best to assist them. I will treat all this new content just like I did the first time I set foot in sky or sea. I will listen to any and all constructive criticism, ask regularly of leadership my job and my place, I will frivolously attempt to gain knowledge of each situation and continue to implement it as I go forward.
For anyone on Odin, if you are willing to allow a "gimp" to join your ranks, tag along, and do his best to be an asset, I will reward you with becoming a key member as soon as it is possible for me to obtain the necessary gear and skills. I shall ask nothing of you other than patience and wisdom. Fair enough proposition ffxiah?
Well said. Too few are able to see the big picture that, even if they are not obligated to do so, helping others will prove helpful to themselves in the long run. Even if that person you helped get a KI or allowed in the farm doesn't directly return the favor, you now potentially have another well-geared player to choose from when you're building your shouts. If everyone was willing to do this once in a while, gimps would cease to be as big a problem.
I know it sounds like I'm being a Pollyanna, but I'm smart enough to know that this would not create an MMO utopia where everyone is skilled, geared, and happy. It'd still be better than what we have now, but I guess as the meme says ain't nobody got time for dat.
By Spiraboo 2013-06-25 10:31:23
people who love the new gear grind vs. those that love old ffxi I vote for ToAU times. Ground Kings always seemed bs to me and sky/sea are dreadful to farm, so that's what I'd say was the best endgame to me!
But being stuck in Faffy's lair for 3 hours with crazy amount of bored people is like one of the best opportunities to get to know each other! XDDD
The community was definitely tighter back then compare to now.
[+]
Asura.Ina
Server: Asura
Game: FFXI
Posts: 17912
By Asura.Ina 2013-06-25 10:36:50
people who love the new gear grind vs. those that love old ffxi I vote for ToAU times. Ground Kings always seemed bs to me and sky/sea are dreadful to farm, so that's what I'd say was the best endgame to me!
But being stuck in Faffy's lair for 3 hours with crazy amount of bored people is like one of the best opportunities to get to know each other! XDDD
The community was definitely tighter back then compare to now. Thats always been something kinda unique to FFXI, there were aspects of the game that were designed for no better reason than to force social interaction. The ship between Mhurah and Selbina being one example, and even the battle system is very chat + play friendly. With most other MMOs it's all about getting you from one fight to the next asap and trying to talk and play will kick you performance in the balls.
[+]
Bismarck.Aselin
Server: Bismarck
Game: FFXI
Posts: 397
By Bismarck.Aselin 2013-06-25 10:37:46
In light of where this conversation is gone ill give my 2cents worth. I have quit the game a few times now for various reasons, and am now returning after a nearly 2 year lapse. I am under leveled, under geared and have no idea how to play any of the new content.
I will, however, do my best to two-box as much content as I possibly can in order to get where I can before asking help and also to get a feel for the game again. Where I find people kind enough to help me, I will return the favor and do my best to assist them. I will treat all this new content just like I did the first time I set foot in sky or sea. I will listen to any and all constructive criticism, ask regularly of leadership my job and my place, I will frivolously attempt to gain knowledge of each situation and continue to implement it as I go forward.
For anyone on Odin, if you are willing to allow a "gimp" to join your ranks, tag along, and do his best to be an asset, I will reward you with becoming a key member as soon as it is possible for me to obtain the necessary gear and skills. I shall ask nothing of you other than patience and wisdom. Fair enough proposition ffxiah?
Well said. Too few are able to see the big picture that, even if they are not obligated to do so, helping others will prove helpful to themselves in the long run. Even if that person you helped get a KI or allowed in the farm doesn't directly return the favor, you now potentially have another well-geared player to choose from when you're building your shouts. If everyone was willing to do this once in a while, gimps would cease to be as big a problem.
I know it sounds like I'm being a Pollyanna, but I'm smart enough to know that this would not create an MMO utopia where everyone is skilled, geared, and happy. It'd still be better than what we have now, but I guess as the meme says ain't nobody got time for dat.
In other words and very simply put: "Pay it forward."
Someone you help today may eventually help you tomorrow-- indirectly or directly. But, all in all, you have added at least one more person that's learned a thing or two fro the content, hopefully, all because you helped them.
I am practically in the same shoes. The same people I've helped a lot in the past have asked me to join their Salvage static and we are helping each other getting and completing gear from there. And, we are helping each other finish relic weapons and eventually mythic and empyrean. The same people I've helped before in an older LS have come back to help me with my Armageddon. In return, for both groups, they are also helping others in their Linkshell and their Friend List, and I help them in return.
It is not a very difficult concept to grasp for others posting in this thread.
...but it just doesn't happen very often.
I'm sure you've heard: Why redo an NM for a KI you already have?
Does the following make sense?
Multiply the xp/cruor/gil/plasm for every person who doesn't have the KI/Kill? So, 18 people go fight Ceizak T5 and 6 people don't have the KI, then maybe he'll drop 6 x 1000 plasm = 6k plasm? (as an example)
Thoughts?
-Felgarr
|
|