Gnarled Horn Or Cloak And Dagger For Tanking?

What do people generally think is better? Or is there some other good atma for tanking?

I used to use Apocalypse, Razed Ruins, and Gnarled Horn, but I just got Cloak and Dagger. Was wondering if it was better than Gnarled Horn?

If you're going to use C&D I'd go with RR/GH/C&D dropping Apoc for it. But I can't really think of a situation where I'd do that.

Dark Depths gives more evasion than Gnarled Horn anyway.

yup only time i dropped GH was for einherjar when spamming my sobeks
still got me on occasion too lol

Atma of the Siren Shadow would be your better choice

Attack+:Major (+40), Evasion+:Major (+40
Enhances "Resist Paralyze" Effect:Major

depends on job?

Depends on job and mob. GH is usually a good compromise between dps and eva, so if you can handle the mob with that go for it. Switch to C&D or SS if the mob has higher acc, depending on the food you are going to use and on mob eva/def. Basically use your brain, there's not a "better" one.
And lol at some of the previous answers.

If you're on an evasive job to start with, RR/GH/DD is going to cap your evasion regardless what gear you're wearing. Your best aid in figuring this stuff out is just to use a parser and see what evade rate you're parsing. If you're evading 80% of the time (getting hit 20% of the time) then you're capped.

GH only gives like 5-10 less evasion than C&D, not worth it really, other than like sobek, like people allready said.