Strigoi Ring would be good too. Also the 7 stat rings are kinda overpriced now from the way I understand it but part of that is not too many people buying and the difficulty of the synergy... still think I should try making monies on them
I'd use gorget over the first two. Third choice will win if acc is capped, lose if uncapped.
Would Ire NQ = Gorget in overall dmg? I been hearing mostly negativity around gorgets , making them pretty low on the list if on the list at all for ws sets that are multi hit. I'm not a mathy person so I'm not certain, if you have any time would you point out which would be a better piece?
I have an Ire NQ and gorget but I have been using Ire as of late, I'm assuming its one of those " if acc isn't capped then gorget , if it is, Ire " kind of situation. Thanks in advance.
Forgot the ire torque, the Rancor Collar is a lot better (inside or outside abyssea).
About your question, the answer is a bit linked with the other gear you have. Inside abyssea NQ ire > gorget. Outside abyssea Gorget > NQ ire (actually outside abyssea gorget > HQ ire).
The best for you is to download the Motenten's spreadsheet and see with the gear you have, the difference between 2 items. If you want to check outside abyssea, remove the atma and the cruor buff (Spec Add).
I'm gonna necro this.. I just got rev fists+2 and I can't see how gorget beats ire+1 for WS..for inside or outside.. Also what's the best MKD helm setup for Smite? Dex+/agi+ crit+/WSdmg+? (for pup mainly but would also double up as my eventual blade:hi piece)
I'm gonna necro this.. I just got rev fists+2 and I can't see how gorget beats ire+1 for WS..for inside or outside.. Also what's the best MKD helm setup for Smite? Dex+/agi+ crit+/WSdmg+? (for pup mainly but would also double up as my eventual blade:hi piece)
Best damage, Crit+ and WSdmg+ should be best bet, with Str+/WSAcc+ replacing Crit+ being a close 2nd if I remember correctly(Which I use myself simply because I'm sure we'll start having accuracy issues again eventually.) Ire+1 DOES beat gorget for WS hands down.
Outside it's an other story, especially in VW and dynamis (at least on NMs)
Anyway like i said it before, you have no reason to buy a ire +1 since it cost the same price that a rancor colar which pwn everything for WS (and TP if you dont care to take more dmg)
Quote:
Best damage, Crit+ and WSdmg+ should be best bet, with Str+/WSAcc+ replacing Crit+ being a close 2nd if I remember correctly
Again, in abyssea onry.
You can not miss the Str+/WSAcc+ outside abyssea (with ws dmg)
Again, in abyssea onry. You can not miss the Str+/WSAcc+ outside abyssea (with ws dmg)
No, even inside abyssea youll be suffering acc issues on scar/hero NMs. If monks have +20skill over pup, along with a perma 25acc from aggress/focus rotation, monk vs pup ws gear in acc, pup probably has more as it probably needs more, but over all monk should still pull ahead with 15-20 more acc overall(counting JA/skill etc). That being said monk barely gets away with that acc on some scar NMs, NMs like Dragua are said to be more evasive so thats something to consider.
Honestly, no reason not to go with ws damage+ 15acc/str regardless of abyssea.(I know you probably know that, but just clearing it up for anoyone else that might have doubts)
Store TP is always useful for DW and H2H jobs unless you're getting TP purely through regain. Rajas + Epona's is the best TP option available right now unless you're in dire need of accuracy.
Honestly, no reason not to go with ws damage+ 15acc/str regardless of abyssea.(I know you probably know that, but just clearing it up for anoyone else that might have doubts)
Ya ya, it was just to answer to Spathaian ^^
Quote:
Rajas + Epona's is the best TP option available right now
For that i saw in motenten's file, the best combo is epona + oneiros (assuming you had some MP merits, and even if you have enough store tp to save a hit). It's not true anymore ?
Quote:
Will Rancor Collar outperform Cirque Necklace
Yep, rancor > everything for tp or ws, inside or outside Abyssea
I'll admit I never specified inside or outside Abyssea when I said what I did. I also still hold that Crit dmg+ and WS dmg+ is still going to do more damage, both inside and out. This is of course going on the assumption that even outside Abyssea we're going to be capped, if not damn near close to it, on accuracy in except on newer things.
However with the newer content, like Voidwatch, where accuracy is becoming relevant again I agree that WSAcc+ and WS dmg+ is a clear winner for PUP, and as I said in my post I have that exact Anwig Salade augment.
stringing pummel does have its moments, that's not to say "don't get victory smite it's a waste of time", but if you're only doing pup as a side project, I'd consider prioritizing better gear over revenant fists +2
For that i saw in motenten's file, the best combo is epona + oneiros (assuming you had some MP merits, and even if you have enough store tp to save a hit). It's not true anymore ?
Sorry, I keep forgetting about that ring because I swapped to HP merits a while back. If you can reasonably expect to keep Oneiros active then yeah, it's generally a better second ring than Rajas.
EDIT: I really don't want to go delving into statistics right now but even if adding Store TP doesn't shave off a hit it should still decrease your average rounds to WS by a % almost identical to the amount of STP added after accounting for existing STP.