Neopets...
I remember getting my first, and only, paintbrush randomly...
Awww I had that in my shop for a long, long time. Then, once they got bitchy about all the html in shops (I had snazzy backgrounds, music, etc), I lost interest.
I'm not biased, half of my friends hate me since I always consider both sides of any stories they rant to me about (usually intense interrogation).